People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Overall we love Smitty’s. Our family has been visiting for years. Amazing wings and pizza. ”
“ Small, Hometown bar/restaurant. What an awesome menu,such variety! We loved our meal! prices were reasonable, service was awesome. Drinks were good. We will absolutely return here on our next drive through town, in one year!! Wish it was closer to home. Would highly recommend stopping here. Dinner and quite a few drinks and still under 60! ”
“ Stopped in on a Sunday late around 7pm, just the time when most restaurants kick ya mediocre food and send you on your way. Can't remember our waitress' name but she was a godsend. Told us she was filling in due to a call off and had been there all day. She was phenomenal. Took care of us and two other packed tables who both arrived same time as us. Food is awesome, drinks are strong, the place is really clean and had a good atmosphere. Definitely worth driving off the highway for. We had the loaded tater tots for an app, highly suggest them. ”
“ My first time at Smitty's, and I have to say . It is the best atmosphere . And the ladies bathroom is decorated so cute decorated in Coca-Cola memorabilia. Our bartender was the best ! I recommend if you're in the area , or if you're not. try going to Smitty's you will not be disappointed. ”
“ We stopped to try somewhere new and they did not disappoint. Great food, reasonably priced and fast service. Great homemade onion rings too! ”
“ We meet here once a month and have lunch. The food is good and the service is exceptional. Nancy takes care of it every time and knows exactly what we drink and what we usually order. She's fast, friendly and efficient she is a big part of why we keep returning. ”
“ Nancy was our waitress. She is outstanding! I had the steak sandwich with homemade batter dipped onion rings. My friend had the Philly cheesesteak. Best sandwiches we’ve had in a very long time. ”
“ Delicious food at good price. Came out fast and really hot. Potatoes just tasted fresh like they just came out of the farm. I really enjoyed the chilly soup as well so highly recommend that. Has a nice kick of black pepper. Plenty of space for semi truck to park so if you are a trucker it's worth coming here if you are in the area. ”
Menu
Ribs
Pork Chops
US$13.991/2 Rack & Chicken
US$20.99Deep Fried
US$12.95Broiled Cod
US$12.95
About
Smitty's Overtime Inn
Welcome to Smitty's Overtime Inn, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Tomah, Wisconsin. Located at 8293 WI-173, this delightful eatery is known for its inviting atmosphere and diverse menu that has something for everyone. With a phone number easily accessible at +1 608-372-5499, you're just a call away from indulging in some of the finest comfort food the area has to offer.
If you're looking for a relaxing spot to unwind after a long week, Smitty's is the place to be. Fridays are highlight evenings with choices like Deep Fried or Broiled Cod, both at just $12.95, and a tantalizing 2-piece walleye meal for $12.99. As the weekend rolls in, elevate your dining experience with their exquisite Prime Rib options on Saturday, featuring the Queen Cut for $18.99 and the King Cut for $21.99. There’s even a Gebhardt Cut, where you can name your size for a truly customized dining experience. And don't miss out on their Sunday brunch buffet available on the 2nd and 4th Sundays, priced at a fantastic $13.99.
The love for Smitty's is palpable among its patrons, with reviews highlighting the exceptional quality of the food and the friendly service. Melissa Salmon, a loyal customer, notes, "Our family has been visiting for years. Amazing wings and pizza." This sentiment is echoed by Jill, who praised the "awesome menu" and reasonable prices that make the dining experience enjoyable without breaking the bank.
But what truly sets Smitty's apart is not just the food; it’s the warm, hometown vibe that makes every visit feel special. On a recent Sunday evening, a satisfied customer named Dave Jr. recounted his experience, expressing gratitude for the phenomenal service that he received even during a busy rush. The loaded tater tots, a recommended appetizer, are a must-try for anyone looking to kickstart their meal with something indulgent.
Katherine Crawford emphasized the charming décor, even noting the adorable Coca-Cola memorabilia in the ladies’ restroom. The attention to detail adds to the overall inviting atmosphere of Smitty's, making it not only a place to eat but also a place to create lasting memories.
Lastly, Sandra Bass couldn’t resist sharing her delight when she discovered the "great homemade onion rings," a testament to the inn’s commitment to quality and taste at reasonable prices. With each dish thoughtfully prepared and a staff dedicated to ensuring a memorable dining experience, Smitty's Overtime Inn stands out as a must-visit spot, whether you're local or just passing through.
Come for the food, stay for the community spirit that makes Smitty's Overtime Inn a beloved establishment in Tomah. You’ll leave with a full belly and a promise to return.
Book a table